Judicial precedent

12 important questions on Judicial precedent

What is the doctrine of precedent in law-making?

  • Doctrine of Precedent: Refers to the source of law where past decisions form future legal guidelines.
  • Promotes fairness and certainty.
  • A type of common law.

What is the hierarchy of the courts for civil cases?

  • Supreme Court (S)
  • Court of Appeal (EA)
  • Divisional Courts (D)
  • High Courts (H)
  • County Courts (C)
  • Magistrates Courts (M)

What is the hierarchy of the courts for criminal cases?

  • Supreme Court (S)
  • Court of Appeal (EA)
  • Queen's Bench Divisional Court (Q)
  • Crown Court (C)
  • Magistrates Court (M)
  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

How are present cases treated under judicial precedent?

  • Present cases are treated as similar to previous ones.
  • Aims to promote fairness.
  • Ensures legal certainty.

What is the principle of stare decisis?

  • Stare decisis means to stand by decisions
  • Ensures consistency in law by adhering to precedents
  • Promotes stability in legal judgments

What are statements made obiter dicta?

  • Statements in a judgment not part of the point of law.
  • Example: Duress cannot be used as a defense to a criminal charge.

What did R v Howe (1987) decide regarding duress?

  • Ruled duress cannot defend a murder charge.
  • Lords commented it's unavailable with someone charged with murder.
  • Followed by R v Gotts (1992).

What is obiter dicta?

  • Obiter dicta includes statements made in passing
  • Does not create binding precedent
  • Complementary remarks to the main judgment

What is the practice statement's role in the Supreme Court?

  • Allows Supreme Court to change law if earlier case was wrongly decided
  • Not frequently used in criminal cases
  • Promotes legal flexibility when necessary

What are the three types of legal precedent?

  1. Original: New decision forms new precedent.
  2. Binding: From an earlier case, binding on future cases.
  3. Persuasive: Not binding, but influential.

Describe the characteristics of an original precedent.

  • Law never decided before.
  • Judge makes new decision.
  • Becomes a new precedent.

How does a persuasive precedent function?

  • Not binding on the court.
  • Judge may consider if principle is similar.
  • Example: R v R (1991) influenced by similar reasoning.

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo